Quality Assurance vs. Quality Control: Why you Need Both in Software Development
Microsoft ended support for XP last year but there are probably millions of computers out there, in homes and offices that are still running the operating system.
How many computers do you see running Vista, the OS that was intended to succeed XP?
Vista was buggy, unreliable, and a massively flawed product. Nobody liked it, and when Windows 7 was released it quickly became extinct in the wild.
However, the failure of Vista has less to do with the radical new look and feel from XP: the success of Windows 7 which took a lot of features from Vista was proof enough that the idea behind Vista was solid enough.
Vista failed so spectacularly because it was a product driven by marketing timelines and fell short in the quality assurance and quality control department.
A lot of people, even programmers, use the terms QA and QC interchangeably.
They are related in that both of these processes are responsible for ensuring that the code performs as advertised.
Before we talk about the differences, it’s instructive to understand what these terms actually mean- let’s take NASA’s definitions (these folks have hundreds of lives and hundreds of billions of dollars riding on the results of tests, so they know what they are talking about).
Software quality assurance is defined as “the function of software quality that assures that the standards, processes, and procedures are appropriate for the project and are correctly implemented”
Software quality control is defined as “the function of software quality that checks that the project follows its standards, processes, and procedures and that the project produces the required internal and external (deliverable) products”.
Quality assurance is:
The goal of quality assurance is to strengthen the software development process so that quality products can be delivered consistently and cost effectively.
Some deliverables that emerge out of the QA tasks include process documentation, detailed requirements, and audit reports.
Quality assurance has nothing to do with execution of code.
Quality control is:
The goal of quality control is to catch the defects in the finished product.
The deliverables from QC include bug reports.
Quality control involves executing code.
A well designed product needs both departments to work together through several iterations.
After QA sets the requirements and the developers write the code the QC department performs a number of tests. The feedback from these tests is shared with QA department who then modifies the requirements and the processes to ensure that the defects don’t pop up in the next version.
In software development methodologies like Agile, both these processes run almost simultaneously.
Quality assurance and quality control cannot be performed by the same person or department as it will lead to a conflict of interest. Both of them are adversarial in nature, in the same way writing is different from editing.
It would be fatal to skip either QA or QC.
If you perform only QA related activities all you will get is a set of processes that seek to improve quality. There is no way of knowing whether the final product will meet these specifications.
On the other hand, without QA you would perform tests in isolation, and fix bugs as they come along without any assurance that the bugs won’t pop up in a later version because of faulty development practices.
QA and QC are tough to do in-house but the problems can magnify in the context of outsourcing because of a multitude of issues around choosing the right outsourcing partner.
However, there are thousands of outsourced projects that have met customer expectations, and all of them had the right mix of process and people.
Invest upfront on quality assurance and quality control, and gain happy users and delighted customers.
Read More: Pros and Cons of Offshore Software Development
Enterprise Software Development: Core Competence or Commodity?
Virtual Reality: A Powerful Tool for the Present and Future of Business Enterprises
CIOs in 2021: New Mindsets, Cultures and Leadership Rules
DataOps: Maximizing Efficiency of your Data
Getting the most from your Multi-Cloud Environment
Six Ingredients of Data Management Intelligence
Top Strategic Priorities for CIOs in 2021
Positioning Your IT for Success in 2021
Customer Centric Processes: From CRM to Customer Data Platforms
Robotic Process Automation: A Driver for Cost-Efficient Enterprises Processes
We're here to help!
No obligation quotes in 48 hours. Teams setup within 2 weeks.
If you are a Service Provider looking to register, please fill out this Information Request and someone will get in touch.
Outsource with Confidence to high quality Service Providers.
If you are a Service Provider looking to register, please fill out
this Information Request and someone will get in
Enter your email id and we'll send a link to reset your password to the address
we have for your account.
The IT Exchange service provider network is exclusive and by-invite. There is
no cost to get on-board;
if you are competent in your areas of focus, then you are welcome. As a part of this exclusive